JoeSportsFan

Last week, the Top 7 looked at some of the worst long-term contracts in baseball history.  It’s a good list to re-visit just about once a year because there are some that are getting worse, some every day (Barry Zito) and some headed there (will Alfonso Soriano even be worth 25 grand a year in five more seasons)? 

This week, showing that we’re not all about negativity, here are the best long-term contracts ever signed in terms of the value that they returned.  For the purposes of the list, it does not count when a guy is just coming into the league, they would have to sign a contract afterwards, so Prince Fielder’s rookie contract can’t be on here even though it’s about as good of a deal as you can have.  The same goes for fliers taken on a guy - Chris Carpenter’s deal with the Cardinals would top that list.  These are long-term deals that actually ended up working out well, and they are kind of hard to find.

7. Todd Helton

todd_helton.jpgHe has three years remaining on his 9-year, $141.5 million contract.  He has never been injured and has a pretty consistent batting average, though his power numbers are way off what they used to be.  He is almost on the list by default because there really aren’t that many long-term deals that work out.

6. Albert Pujols

Even though the contract doesn’t run out until 2010 (with an option for ’11), Pujols could not play another game and it would still be a good value.  Four years in, he has a championship, an MVP, and has set an all-time record for fan-based man crushes.  As a comparison, Scott Rolen’s deal was just $10 million less, and Carlos Lee’s was the same amount of money for one fewer season.  It’s a steal, and could easily be #1 if he stays healthy through the duration. 

5. Manny Ramirez

manuelbeingmanuel.jpgWhen he turned down Cleveland’s deal and signed with Boston for 8 years and $160 million, it seemed like an insane amount of money, until two things happened—A-Rod signing for almost $100 million more, and Manny being…a guy who was worth it.  He has finished in the top 20 of MVP every year including the top 10 each year but one (plus he would be the MVP so far this season), has two titles, and a World Series MVP.  He also has 260 homers and a batting average well over .300.  It’s amazing that even in the last year of such a massive deal that he is still giving them value.

4. Vladimir Guerrero

He is in the last year of a 5-year, $70 million contract, and anytime there is no question as to whether an option will be picked up, you know it’s a good deal.  $14 million a year for Guerrero is less than what Torii Hunter and Vernon Wells receive, and is the exact same amount that JD Drew receives.  Playing on the west coast doesn’t help for his attention, but he has never hit fewer than 29 homers, had an average less than .317, or finished lower than 9th in MVP voting since he signed with Anaheim/LA.

3. Mark Buehrle

It’s even harder for pitchers to make appearances on the list, but Buehrle definitely deserves it—he put in two extremely solid years on a 3-year, $18 million deal with the White Sox, and though his third year wasn’t amazing, two great ones and a World Series for next to nothing (in starting pitcher terms) is an incredible deal.

pedrozimmer.jpg2. Pedro Martinez

He signed a 6-year, $75 million deal with the Red Sox, and was probably worth at least two times that.  He put up ERAs that almost don’t look like they are real when you see them on his Baseball Reference page, including 1.74 job during a year when Bobby Higginson hit 30 home runs.

1. Ken Griffey Jr.

The Mariners signed him long-term after his fourth year in the majors, paying him $6 million a year for four years, and ended up getting some of the best seasons by a player his age in the history of baseball.

The Top 7 is written by Jason Major.  He signed a 4 year deal to be teacher at a public school and got extra copies of Where the Red Fern Grows as part of his signing bonus.  Email him at jason@joesportsfan.com
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Fark
name:
comment:
 
NaN, May 9, 2008 04:05 AM
Buehrle? Are you serious? It wasn't a bad deal, but a 3 year contract to buy out some arbitration years doesn't seem noteworthy at all. Sloppy list.
Adam, April 27, 2008 05:04 AM
The list doesn't seem to well thought out.You call it long term, and have a 3 year deal on there. 3 years isn't long term. And if Todd Helton's deal is so worth it, then how come the Rockies spent a month trying to trade him last Spring Training?
Go Braves!, April 26, 2008 05:04 PM
Glad you didn't include Johan Santana and Mike Hampton.
Chubbs, April 25, 2008 07:04 PM
Funny, No Dodgers
John, April 25, 2008 01:04 PM
Nick Swisher or Dan Haren deserve to be on here
Rocky Mtn Highball, April 25, 2008 12:04 PM
Obviously there should've been a "Post Free-Agency" in the title of this list, since prior to that players were pretty much indentured servants. I also have to note that this might be the most "serious" Top-7 ever, great work! Can I propose a "Top-7 Worst NFL Draft Picks" for next week?...surely there could even be a few from tomorrow's draft!
Kilo, April 25, 2008 10:04 AM
Ironically, Ken Griffey Jr.'s Reds contract could easily be the worst of all time.
Patrick, April 25, 2008 07:04 AM
Inflation raises a good point. I guess when you consider Griffey's contract in 92/93 to Bonds as noted in the comments, the Griffey one definitely wins out and sheds some light on the financial era.
Inflation, April 25, 2008 07:04 AM
Is it fair to consider a contract that started 15 years ago as a value? Wouldn't Mickey Mantle make the list in that case? The Reds offered to trade 6 loaves of bread for Mantle on the last day of the 1956 season and the Yankees almost took it.
Joseph, April 25, 2008 07:04 AM
This list is wack. Easily the best contract had to be Randy Johnson's four year deal with the D-Backs back in the offseason of 1998. He won a Cy Young award every year of his deal. Also i remember him helping them win a World Series or something.
Patrick, April 25, 2008 06:04 AM
Wow... Major won't be able to sleep once he reads the comment about Bonds.
Badsin, April 25, 2008 05:04 AM
I have a hardcore man crush on Chase Utley
Mrs. D, April 25, 2008 05:04 AM
Anybody else surprised that two signings by Dan Duquette made this list?
Colin D, April 25, 2008 04:04 AM
ARE YOU GUYS CRAZY!?!?!?! There is no doubt bonds' first contract with the giants is the bar for best contract EVER. It was 6 years/$43.75M (1993-98). In case you were wondering, Bonds' OPS was 1.135 his first year in '93.Case closed
Matthew Berhman, April 25, 2008 04:04 AM
Evan Longoria for 6 years/17.5 Mil and options through 2016 will be number one or two by '09!
Mr. Irrelevant, April 25, 2008 04:04 AM
For sure Aramis Ramirez's 5yr 75 million contract will be on this list by the time it's done.
Patrick, April 25, 2008 03:04 AM
Chase Utley is the man.
Jeff, April 25, 2008 03:04 AM
How about Chase Utley at 7 Years, 85 Million. Looking like a steal now huh?
G., April 25, 2008 02:04 AM
er... $160 million, I meant.
G., April 25, 2008 02:04 AM
Great list. It's amazing that a $160 contract is "value".

Al Cowens

As the four fans in Section 312 found out the day this picture was taken, you do not want to heckle Al Cowens during a photo shoot.

See More Cards