I offer vigorous head shakes at your work
It is a "dire" time in sports history right now. With all the controversies and scandals hovering over the major sports, people like Bill Plaschke are pontificating from their pulpets. Some journalists take the complete opposite approach, however. At a time like this, awesome, award-winning writers are using their power and their "gift" to talk about... the hype and commercialization of Harry Potter. (!!!) (!!!)
Yup.
Mitch Albom spent 594 words bashing the Harry Potter empire for ruining the classic kids books. I shit you not. You need to read the whole column, which goes by fast anyway because Albom perfects the art of one sentence paragraphs like all good elitist-journalists do.
Read the column below if you choose. Albom's words are smaller font so it's easy to distinguish his words and mine. If you don't feel like reading about Clifford the Big Red Dog getting shafted, you can just skip down to my reaction (or just close your browser and tell me to go eff myself... doesn't matter to me).
________
It was just after midnight Friday when a rustling came from a pile of books under a bed. And suddenly, out crawled Winnie the Pooh, a jar of honey under his arm. Behind him were Tigger, Eeyore and Piglet.
Together, they climbed the wall, pushed open the window, and took one last look.
"Where are you going?" I asked.
"Someplace where they appreciate us," Pooh said. "Someplace where every child isn't buying ..."
He sighed. "Oh, bother," he said.
Pooh and the others snuck down a drain spout, then tiptoed along the street. From the darkness, they were joined by Horton the Elephant and the spider from "Charlotte's Web," both carrying suitcases.
"Wait for moi!" yelled a small voice.
The Little Prince.
As they snuck along the curb, they peeked into houses. Through every window, there was a child engrossed in the new and final Harry Potter book, "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows." No one noticed their escape.
"How depressing," Pooh whispered.
Something stirred. From a nearby telephone pole, Curious George swung down. "Wait up!" he yelled.
"I thought you never spoke," Charlotte said.
"That was just in the book," he said, shrugging his monkey shoulders. "To be honest, I'm not even that curious. I just like to get into stuff and make a mess."
The parade grows
They trudged along, joined every block by other once-favorite children's literature characters. Pippi Longstocking. Clifford the Big Red Dog. James and the Giant Peach. A big cupboard came thumping out, opened its doors, and out fell the Indian.
"It's no use," he said. "I tried killing him with a tomahawk. But he just put a spell on it."
Apparently, with more than 300 million books sold, five blockbuster movies, endless merchandising, Web sites and commercial hype, Harry Potter had simply taken over children's reading.
Dominated it. Swallowed it. If a fictional character could be a tsunami, Harry was it.
"Who cares about a cat in a hat?" said the Cat in the Hat. "All they want now is evil spells and Quidditch."
"And muggles and Death Eaters."
"And green eggs and ham?"
"Nice try, Sam," said Peter Rabbit.
Suddenly, a car came barreling into a driveway, and the characters had to scatter. The car door opened and out stepped a family with bags from Borders.
"What'd they buy?" asked Stuart Little.
"Don't be naive," said Nancy Drew.
There used to be room
Once, it seemed, there was room for all kinds of kids books. Tigers and spiders and princes and Indians. But these days, it's all Harry. Harry in print. Harry online. Harry in theaters. Harry at the toy store.
Never has a hype machine worked harder to make a big thing bigger. Never has the media so gleefully jumped on a bandwagon of countdowns, hints and contests.
"It ain't fair," said Huck Finn. "He gets like 4,000 pages. What'd I get, less than 400 -- counting pictures?"
"I wish I had his publicist," said Hansel.
"I wish I had his money," said Gretel.
They made their way down to the river, where one by one, they boarded a small boat, a Noah's ark for literary creations.
"Wait, don't go!" implored Alice in Wonderland. "Harry Potter is just a fad. It will pass."
The Little Prince pushed off, yelled "Au revoir!" and the boat floated away, flanked by one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish.
"At least say where you're going!" I yelled.
"We're going to the only place we know that they're sick of Harry Potter!" roared Babar the Elephant.
"Where's that?"
"Hogwarts."
Contact MITCH ALBOM at 313-223-4581 or malbom@freepress.com.
_______
FADE OUT.
Wheewwwww.
Let's first look at this from the perspective of a non-sports fan and pretend Mitch Albom wasn't a regular panelist on ESPN's The Sports Reporters, but instead, the Lifetime's The Potty Trainers (*clever*). Even someone who took this column for what it wasn't (it was crap) would note that Harry Potter books/movies aren't exactly intended for 3,4 and 5 year olds. The books have "grown" with the audience. By now, the target audience is not the people who read Clifford and Pooh Bear - it's for ages 9, 10 and up. Teens and adults are into it as much as anybody else.
Let's now look at this from the perspective of a sports fan, who often wonders how Mitch Albom has a job as a columnist, and how he is consistently airing his greivances every Sunday morning on ESPN: WRITE ABOUT SOMETHING! EVEN IF IT'S NOT SPORTS (apparently you aren't just a sports columnist, which is fine), BUT WRITE ABOUT SOMETHING! ANYTHING!
The theme of the above column is this: "Harry Potter sucks because it's taking over our children. It's a commercialized hype machine. Whatever happened to the good old days? And what about those classic characters, the ones who did it the right way?".
That commercialized hype machine did wonders for you and your books, Mitch, which turned into movies and landed you appearances on morning talk shows and Oprah. I smell a little hypocrisy.
And I got news for ya, Albom: Clifford the Big Red Dog didn't do it the right way. He juiced as much as anyone (it's kind of obvious, no?). And Charlotte the spider? She wasn't too cute when she weaved the words "BACON" and "HOMOSEXUAL" for Wilbur the Pig. And Pooh was stoned all the time - he always lost his train of thought and constantly craved food.
All I know is, if Mitch Albom was my father, I would kick the living crap out of him.
Note: tip of the cap to Sports Frog for the heads up. Also check out FireJoeMorgan for an awesome rant on Albom's Sunday colleague Mike Lupica, for a "column" Lupica wrote about A-Rod not owning Yankees' stripes or something really stupid like that.
Sadly, Butch was the only one who failed to recognize the irony of his first name.